Congress passed a law allowing widespread oil exploration on federal lands in the western United States. A large deposit of oil sand was discovered in one western state and Congress authorized an oil sand refining plant to be built on federal park land within the state. The refinery was built in compliance with federal pollution regulations. Pursuant to state law, the plant manager allowed the state to inspect the plant before putting it into operation. Because state refinery standards were more strict than the federal standards (in order to better protect state citizens from pollution associated with refineries), the refinery did not pass the inspection, and the state inspector refused to give the manager a permit to run the refinery. The refinery manager nevertheless began to run the refinery and was fined by the state.
Which of the following is the manager's best defense against imposition of the fine?

A) The state does not have a compelling interest in regulating the refinery, because it is within a federal park
B) The state regulation is invalid because Congress has preempted the field of pollution control
C) The state pollution regulation is invalid because it is inconsistent with the state's compelling interest in providing jobs
D) The state law violates the principles of intergovernmental immunity as applied to the manager

Question

02-04-2021
Business

Answered

Get the answers you need at Westonci.ca, where our expert community is dedicated to providing you with accurate information. Get the answers you need quickly and accurately from a dedicated community of experts on our Q&A platform. Join our platform to connect with experts ready to provide precise answers to your questions in different areas.

Congress passed a law allowing widespread oil exploration on federal lands in the western United States. A large deposit of oil sand was discovered in one western state and Congress authorized an oil sand refining plant to be built on federal park land within the state. The refinery was built in compliance with federal pollution regulations. Pursuant to state law, the plant manager allowed the state to inspect the plant before putting it into operation. Because state refinery standards were more strict than the federal standards (in order to better protect state citizens from pollution associated with refineries), the refinery did not pass the inspection, and the state inspector refused to give the manager a permit to run the refinery. The refinery manager nevertheless began to run the refinery and was fined by the state.
Which of the following is the manager's best defense against imposition of the fine?

A) The state does not have a compelling interest in regulating the refinery, because it is within a federal park
B) The state regulation is invalid because Congress has preempted the field of pollution control
C) The state pollution regulation is invalid because it is inconsistent with the state's compelling interest in providing jobs
D) The state law violates the principles of intergovernmental immunity as applied to the manager

Sagot :

We hope this was helpful. Please come back whenever you need more information or answers to your queries. Thank you for choosing our platform. We're dedicated to providing the best answers for all your questions. Visit us again. Get the answers you need at Westonci.ca. Stay informed with our latest expert advice.

Audrey can use the library catalogue for which three purposes? a.find a specific title b.see if the library is open next weekend c.search for an author d.see if

The purpose of an AOA indicator is to give the pilot better situational awareness pertaining to the aerodynamic health of the airfoil. This can also be referred

Neural regeneration can occur if:A) The cell body is intactB) The damage occurs within the dendrites onlyC) The Nissl bodies are released from the axon terminal

Why is using APA Style important for effective scholarly writing? a. Style guidelines distinguish psychology from other fields of scientific research. b. Consis

The exponential expression [tex]$\left(\frac{1}{8}\right)^4$[/tex] is equivalent to which of the following? Explain your choice.A. [tex]$4^{-8}$[/tex]B. [te

Rate of reaction- chemistry

Question 9Two arcs of a circle are congruent if and only if their associated chords are perpendicular.A. TrueB. False

Write an application problem whose solution depends on solving the equation 4x+20=190

how much more output per year will have to be produced in the world just to provide the 3 billion “severely” poor population with$0.59 more income per day?

Enzyme inhibition decreases the ability of an enzyme to catalyze a reaction. There are several forms of enzyme inhibition . Choose the type of inhibition involv

topeadeniran2 topeadeniran2 · Answer 1 · 2021-04-07T23:39:57-04:00

Answer: D. The state law violates the principles of intergovernmental immunity as applied to the manager

Explanation:

Based on the information given, the manager's best defense against the imposition of the fine is that the state law violates the principles of intergovernmental immunity as applied to the manager.

We should note that unless Congress agrees to a particular regulation, the state doesn't have the power to regulate federal government activities and therefore cannot interfere with federal functions. Therefore, the regulation in this case isn't applicable to the manager.

Sagot :

Other Questions