Is this a good compare-contrast essay?

“Stray” and “Lone Dog” are very different, but they are very similar, because for example in “Stray” “the puppy had been abandoned and it made its way down the road towards the Lacey’s small house its ears tucked in its tail between its legs shivering” and in “Lone Dog” “ I’m a lean dog a keen dog a wild dog and lone; I’m a rough dog a tough dog hunting on my own.” These sentences show the similarity between the two texts that these dogs were both alone. The is also very different because, for example, in “Stray” “Doris trenched through the yard, went up the shoveled drive and met the dog “come on pooch.” In this dog was found. In “Lone Dog” “I’ll never be a lap dog licking dirty feet; a sleek dog, a meek dog cringing for my meat, not for me the fireside, the well-filled plate but shut door and shut down, and cuff and kick and hate. These two show the differences between the two texts, and in here the dog still stays alone. These differences and similarities help us better understand the texts.