Discover answers to your most pressing questions at Westonci.ca, the ultimate Q&A platform that connects you with expert solutions. Join our platform to connect with experts ready to provide accurate answers to your questions in various fields. Get immediate and reliable solutions to your questions from a community of experienced professionals on our platform.

Fourteen legislative seats are being apportioned among 3 states resulting in the standard quotas and geometric means shown in the following table.

| State | Standard Quota | Geom. Mean |
|--------|----------------|------------|
| State 1| 2.67 | 2.45 |
| State 2| 6.92 | 6.48 |
| State 3| 4.17 | 4.47 |

Using the Huntington-Hill method, what is the apportionment?

A. 2, 7, 5
B. 2, 6, 5
C. 3, 7, 4
D. 2, 7, 4


Sagot :

To determine the apportionment of fourteen legislative seats among the three states using the Huntington-Hill method, we follow these steps:

1. Initial Allocation:
- Allocate to each state the integer part of their standard quota.
- State 1: The standard quota is 2.67. The integer part is 2.
- State 2: The standard quota is 6.92. The integer part is 6.
- State 3: The standard quota is 4.17. The integer part is 4.

2. Calculate Initial Seats:
- State 1: 2 seats
- State 2: 6 seats
- State 3: 4 seats
- Total allocated seats initially: [tex]\(2 + 6 + 4 = 12\)[/tex]

3. Remaining Seats to Allocate:
- Total seats to allocate: 14
- Seats already allocated: 12
- Remaining seats: [tex]\(14 - 12 = 2\)[/tex]

4. Ratios for Huntington-Hill Method:
- Compute the ratios as follows:
- For each state, the ratio is [tex]\(\frac{\text{standard quota}}{\sqrt{\text{seats} \times (\text{seats} + 1)}}\)[/tex].
- State 1: [tex]\(\frac{2.67}{\sqrt{2 \times 3}} = \frac{2.67}{\sqrt{6}}\)[/tex]
- State 2: [tex]\(\frac{6.92}{\sqrt{6 \times 7}} = \frac{6.92}{\sqrt{42}}\)[/tex]
- State 3: [tex]\(\frac{4.17}{\sqrt{4 \times 5}} = \frac{4.17}{\sqrt{20}}\)[/tex]

5. Allocate Remaining Seats:
- We need to allocate the 2 remaining seats to the states with the highest ratios.
- Check the ratios calculated to decide which state gets the next seat.
- Allocate one seat at a time and update the ratios accordingly.

Following this step-by-step procedure, the final allocation of seats results in:

- State 1 ends up with 3 seats.
- State 2 ends up with 7 seats.
- State 3 ends up with 4 seats.

Thus, the apportionment is [tex]\((3, 7, 4)\)[/tex].

This matches option (C) in the provided options:
(C) [tex]\(3, 7, 4) So, the correct answer is: (C) \(3, 7, 4\)[/tex]